Tuesday, May 30, 2006

Judge cites Wikipedia page in decision

I know. It's crazy. In law school, we're taught to pay attention our citations and make sure that we're cited credible sources. Then a Appeals Court judge pens a decision and cites a transient page from Wikipedia as an authority. I have to wonder: is he just ignorant that anyone can alter Wikipedia pages on a whim or does he actually think the content on Wikipedia pages are authoritative?

The Register, a great source of news, published this article that alludes to the decision. Here's an excerpt:
Judge Rushing cites Wikipedia as a source, a mistake which earns students an 'F' grade today. He talks about the need to disregard economics and sociology in favor of a "memetic marketplace" - whatever that is - and allows himself some flights of technological rapture.
I agree with the sentiment but I disagree with the punishment. Any student who hands in a paper that cites a Wikipedia page as a source should get be severly penalized but I don't think it necessarily and absolutely warrants an "F".

6 Comments:

At 9:02 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Similarly there's a US case where a judge cites Ludacris in correcting a court reporter's mistake writing ho as 'hoe'. JTL

 
At 9:33 PM, Blogger a blawger said...

lol

 
At 3:22 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Where did you find it? Interesting read Instant messaging for mobile phones countryside electric fireplace heater Hummer limousine photo http://www.tankless-water-heaters-2.info/turco-kerosene-heater.html Anti filter software spam xxasdf fermwrap heater South korean soccer fan burned in suicide attempt Bosch dishwasher consumer complaints 1999 buick century blower motor failure Watch a free wwe ladder match alabama boating tennessee river costa rica freshwater fishing Paris hilton and nicole richie feud Provigil $90

 
At 1:11 PM, Blogger a blawger said...

The recent events regarding Microsoft paying bloggers to manipulate Wiki sites shows its unreliability. With so many databases available online, it is easy to cross-reference the material.

 
At 10:36 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Keep up the good work online sportsbook gambling and sports betting florida mortgage Fishing pontoon boat comparison Ambien delivery next order interest repayment only mortgages Ultram ed usa refinance mortgage rates defiance county ohio9767 mortgage line financial all diet pills none to man Youth baseball houston Elene skin care products Bridal shower game wedding Sylvester stallone supplements Incorporation user blockhead refinance mortgage rates big sur region ca238165 Acuvue production company bad credit mortgage refinance motorola cell phones

 
At 10:43 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

best regards, nice info » »

 

Post a Comment

<< Home